Skip to main content.

planet earth
Filer's Files
By George Filer

MUFON Eastern Region Director
August 28, 2000

George Filer:
See all the photos at:


Jeff Challender who is doing excellent work with the NASA Shuttle footage wrote, "Have you ever thought of doing a story on the now little known Robertson Panel of January, 1953? This is the origin of the official policy, of ridicule and debunking at all costs, against those of "credible stature" who might dare to report UFOs or "uncorrelated targets". Yet few in the public are aware of this Panel and its' recommendations. People should know about this. IF there is "nothing" to the UFO phenomenon, it doesn't make sense to create a policy of aggressive attacks on witnesses. Why work so hard, expend so much energy and time, and spend so much tax dollars to counter "NOTHING"?

Well Jeff. there really is a national policy to ridicule UFO reports. The US government's own historical documents obtained through the Freedom of Information Act explain why it became US government's policy to debunk, mock, and discredit anyone who provides good evidence for UFOs. In the late 1940s early 1950s, the numerous reports from high quality witnesses was putting the government in a precarious and embarrassing position. Leading the revelations were Major Donald Keyhoe and Vice Admiral Roscoe Hillenkotter the third director of the CIA (1947 to 1950) who declared UFOs were real. UFOs were reported in headlines buzzing Washington DC and flying at will over our military bases. The Cold War with the Soviets and Communist countries was heating up. Strange craft were reported all over our skies, and the news media was critical of government's explanations. Many thought the craft belonged to the Soviet Union or perhaps aliens bent on invasion. There was fear the Soviets could use UFO propaganda to discredit the US government. There was genuine concern that a national panic could occur. Whether UFOs were real or not, the situation made the president nervous, the military and the various intelligence agencies look bad. Plenty of good reports were leaking out and thousands of military aircraft were crashing. Stories started leaking out these aircraft were crashing while chasing UFOs. The crashes were explained has training accidents and mechanical failures but the news media was starting to tie the two types of reports together. Best selling books were claiming the UFOs were real and might signal a Soviet or alien invasion. The situation whether real or unreal was deteriorating. The Robertson Panel was formed at the request of the White House to quell the situation. It was not unlike the Warren Commission or Waco Hearings where the public wanted answers. So powerful forces in the CIA, Air Force and the scientific establishment came together to cool the UFO state of affairs.

CIA documents reveal five members of the Scientific Advisory Panel who were known skeptics were given several poor UFO cases to examine and came to the conclusion that "there was no evidence of a direct threat to national security in the objects sighted. Flying saucer reports were overloading emergency reporting channels with false information, clogging up communication lines, causing alarm, and realistically even if they were real there was little we could do about them. Further the government was losing the confidence of the people. Our science and aircraft seemed to be confronted by far superior technology. The Robertson Panel discussions and recommendations centered around the main problem of eradicating belief in these unidentified flying objects. Ways of bringing in the news media, and movies were discussed. CIA documents reveal, one of the panel's recommendations was that a policy of debunking UFO reports should be instigated. This would result in reduction in public interest in flying saucers which today evokes a strong psychological reaction. This media such as television, motion pictures, and popular articles. Basis of such education would be actual case histories which had been puzzling at first but later explained. As is the case of continuing tricks, there is much less stimulation if the secret is known. Such a program should tend to reduce the current gullibility of the public and consequently there susceptibility to clever hostile propaganda."

The CIA reports reveal a national policy of debunking UFO reports. Like was instigated and the power of the government was set in motion to debunk the field. The panel discussed the various insidious methods that could be implemented to execute such a program: It was felt strongly that psychologists familiar with mass psychology should advise on the nature and extent of the program. These national programs resulted in the National Policy became to debunk any valid sighting even if it resulted the embarrassment of pilots and government employees. UFO reports were denied, debunked and those who see them ridiculed. Timothy Good in his book Above Top Secret writes: Another sinister recommendation of the panel was that civilian UFO groups should be watched "because of their potentially great influence on mass thinking if widespread sighting s should occur. The apparent irresponsibility and the possible use of such groups for subversive purposes should be kept in mind." The panel concluded that "the continued emphasis on the reporting these phenomena does, in these parlous times, result in a threat to the orderly functioning of the protective organs of the body politic," and recommended:

a. That the national security agencies take immediate steps to strip the Unidentified Flying Objects of the special status they have been given and the aura of mystery they have unfortunately acquired.

b. That the national security agencies institute policies on intelligence, training, and public education designed to prepare the material defenses and the morale of the country to recognize most promptly and to react most effectively to true indications of hostile intent or action. P. 338

Shortly thereafter every effort of the government went into debunking UFOs even if it would mean embarrassing its own people. It soon became known the best way to destroy your military career was to report a UFO. Captain Edward J. Ruppelt, Chief of the Aerial Phenomena Branch at the Air Technical Intelligence Center, said that the CIA ordered the Air Force to debunk sightings and debunk witnesses. "We're ordered to hide sightings when possible," he told Major Keyhole, but if a strong report does get out we have to publish a fast explanation--make up something to kill the report in a hurry, and also ridicule the witness, especially if we can't figure out a plausible answer. even have to discredit our own pilots." P.339

The millions of dollars spent by the Air Force to debunk the Roswell report show this policy is still strongly in effect. It's an uphill climb to bring out the reality of the situation. If a group of military people observe a UFO and the case has merit, they are quickly transferred or retired to keep the observers from talking and told to keep quiet with various threats. Every time I see a strong debunking article that tears at the reputation of a courageous UFO researcher, I wonder who the debunker is working for? If you study Ufology, you soon discover in almost every important case there will be an attempt to ridicule those who bring the pro UFO evidence forward. The better the case the stronger criticism. Frequently this is led by a small but ferocious group who seem to claim every sighting is the planet Venus or a hoax. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but they usually attack the researcher rather than the data. The attacks are vindictive towards the person rather than his research or sighting. I always wonder if the attackers are paid to conduct these character assassinations? One favorite tactic is to attack the person for any attempt to obtain a financial reward for researching UFOs. Some how in every other field its all right to make a living accept in Ufology. I'm happy to stand up in court to testify or debate anyone on the reality of UFOs. The Cold War is over, so now many who were once government employees are questioning these methods. The intensity of the government actions tend to prove UFOs exist. Perhaps the policy needs review. Almost fifty years have gone by since these debunking methods and ridicule became national policy. I feel its time for a change.


It should be realized that about half of UFO reports involve oceans, lakes and rivers. UFOs are frequently seen going to and from water, entering and leaving the water or traveling under the water. For example, Ivan T. Sanderson writes, "The trawler Star of Freedom (70 tons) from Fleetwood, Lancashire, struck an unidentified object in the early hours of February 3, 1965. She was steaming at the time at nine knots in 80 fathoms, 15 miles E.S.E. of Barra, Scotland. The crash lifted the bow out of the water. A distress call was sent out, and the crew manned the pumps. Eventually the badly holed trawler was beached in Castlebay harbor. Skipper George Wood is convinced that he hit a surfacing submarine, but both British and American naval authorities denied that any of the their submarines had been involved. "Invisible Residents" The book has hundreds of accounts of underwater craft not believed to be operated by humans.

It is interesting to note that the Russian Navy and government is still insisting that the most likely cause of the Kursk sub disaster was a collision with a foreign submarine. The Norwegian Seismic Institute indicates that explosions were detected at 11.28 AM and 11.39 AM Russian time on August 12, in the vicinity of the sub. The second was a powerful explosion that registered 3.5 on the Richter scale. It is possible that some type of underwater collision could have caused events that led up to the second large explosion that apparently blew a hole in the front of the sub. The Russians claim the last contact with the vessel was on August 11, when the Kirsch's commander Gennady Lyachin, successfully test-fired a missile during a military exercise. He asked permission to fire again on Saturday morning. The missile that may have exploded in its launch tube is a rocket-propelled anti-submarine weapon an SSN15 or an SSN16. The missile is fired like a torpedo but its rocket launches it to the target area where it reenters the water and destroys the enemy sub. This offensive action may have caused the unknown foreign sub to respond by taking offensive action against the Kursk. If the sub accidentally hit an underwater object the torpedo rocket may have exploded causing heavy damage to the sub. We may never know what exactly caused the accident in relatively shallow water not much deeper than the length of a football field.

We should not forget almost three quarters of the Earth is covered by water that averages two miles in depth. That is 280 million cubic miles of water. Most of this area has never been explored by humans. We know that life forms lived in the oceans hundreds of millions of years before life came to land. Human embryos go through development that infers we were fishlike at one time in the distant past. It is possible a civilization millions perhaps a billion years older than our own developed with intelligent aquatic creatures. I'm writing this story from the New Jersey shore whereas far as I can see is the ocean. I went swimming this morning and found strange creatures in the water. At least they were strange to me. One I photographed had the shape of a disc and was made of a type of a hard clear plastic like substance. Apparently it was from the jelly fish family but enlarged hundreds of times this material could be made into a unique underwater city. It could withstand tremendous pressure without collapsing. Close by was a small crab with pinchers holding a small fish. Porpoises and whales are said to possess intelligence equal to man. Equipped with pinchers or fingers they would have the ability to manufacture objects. Those who live under the sea may be either air breathing or liquid breathing. Looking at these creatures from the ocean I wondered if over millions of years an underwater civilization could have advanced to build flying objects. UFOs may be from this planet or from somewhere in space but they are frequently seen plunging through our atmosphere and diving into the ocean. We actually know very little about what is beneath the sea and if someone lives there they may not want to be found.


GETTYSBURG -- Marilyn J. Ruben writes: "I thought you would enjoy seeing the UFO photo I took Sunday afternoon August 20, 2000, at 3:09 PM. while our family was on vacation in Gettysburg. We were driving the route through the Civil War battlefields of Gettysburg and periodically got out of the car to take pictures. I was using the Sony digital still camera. The photo is a close-up of what is known as the "Copse of Trees" (meaning clump of trees). It is in the middle of a large field in Gettysburg in an area where 20,000 confederates charged across this field to attack union soldiers hiding in the "copse of trees." About one-third of the Confederate soldiers were killed here in July of 1863. Pickett's Charge was a turning point in the Civil War. I found the battleground to be as moving an experience. After reviewing the photos today, I was surprised to discover two UFOs hovering in on either side of the "Copse of Trees." The two UFOs were not there when I took the picture, since I had been watching he skies continuously for UFOs. It seemed as if the UFOs were watching over Gettysburg. The photos can be seen at the Alien Abduction Experience and Research web site Editors Note: The objects are rather small, but enlarged they appear to be discs with domes.


RINGGOLD - On August 15, 2000, I was driving down one of the major roads that connects Ft Oglethorpe to Ringgold at 01:50 AM. I noticed a ball of light moving across the sky that was too fast and low to be a plane, and too slow to be a falling star. The light moved across the sky and started to disappear behind some tree tops, but made a huge U-turn back toward me. As it turned, I noticed it had two lights on it, but as it came closer I saw three white colored lights. Two larger ones were on the sides, and other was in the middle. Higher up was a small red flashing light in between the three white ones. It was hovering in the air above a house while I was stopped. I then decided to hightail it home. I kept looking back for the object but I didn't see it. As I neared my home, I put my turn signal on and saw the aircraft was directly above my driveway. I could clearly see the three lights and the flashing light. The craft had some kind of blue and red reflective checkerboard pattern on the bottom. I stopped my car at the top of my driveway and watched the craft as it made it's way across the sky and slowly flew over the top of my car, and crept off over my house until it disappeared into the darkness. I waited in my car for a few minutes to make sure it was gone, and ran inside. Thanks to Peter Davenport NUFORC


MINNESOTA RIVER - MUFON's William I. McNeff reports that a witness observed lights while night fishing on August 5, 2000, at 11:45 to 12:10 PM three miles east of Le Sueur. The witness says, "I was watching the catfish lines and the frequent falling stars, when I looked north to the lowest part of the spoon in the Big Dipper constellation. I watched a light become bright as it moved in what would become a southerly direction. I assumed, that the increase in light intensity was due to the sun's reflection on a satellite. I noticed that it was a slower speed than any of the other six satellites I had observed earlier that evening. I saw another light appear behind it that was maybe 1/2" at arm's-length. From the time I saw the first, until the second appeared, was 20 seconds. The speed of one was erratic at best. Using the stars in the background, I was able to verify that they traveled less a trajectory, but rather in a meandering direction, neither holding a constant speed. The second never passed the first. Then, as they were at a point I would describe as 11 O'clock, I saw the third. They seemed to "inch-worm" across the sky, all wavering slightly in direction, in a loose formation. The second seemed to act as a "chase-plane", like the Tigers that follow the Shuttle's entry. Sometimes, the second would slow to alongside the third, making equilateral triangle, sometimes drop behind, but not for long. It seemed intent on trying to hold its own position in the formation. I watched them for 5 minutes, as they crossed the arc of the sky. They faded out of light in the S-SE, as would a satellite re-entering the Earth's shadow. That's one of the reasons I say their altitude was orbit-level. Thanks to Jeffrey Pekarna. Le Sueur and MUFON's William I. McNeff


SEATTLE -- I saw Linda Lull's report Filer's Files #32 that remind me of the sighting I had on July 23, 2000, around 4:30 PM., I was driving north on Interstate 5, near the Shorline district of Seattle. The sky in front of me was crystal clear blue. Looking up I saw a very bright light in the north west sky that was 1/16 of an inch held at arm's length. My impression is that the object was metallic and the brightness was caused by the reflecting sunlight. The object appeared to be stationary although since I was in a moving vehicle that can't be confirmed. I watched the object for perhaps two minutes when it suddenly just vanished or "winked out" as it is sometimes described. I probably would not have made the report to NUFORC if it hadn't been for the unusual fact that it just vanished before my eyes after being so prominently in view. Thanks to Gary Val Tenut at


Ilias Chrissochoidis writes, "As a doctoral student in the Humanities, I've been spending much time reading 18th-century British periodicals. In one of them I have found a report of an unexplained phenomenon. I leave it to your judgment and experience to decide its merits as a UFO sighting. Extract of a letter from Edinburgh, Sept. 8, 1767 follows:

"We hear from Perthsire, that an uncommon phaenomenon was observed on the water of Isla, near Cupor Angus, preceded by a thick dark smoke, which soon dispelled, and discovered a large luminous body, like a house on fire, but presently after took a form something pyramidal, and rolled forwards with impetuosity till it came to the water of Erick, up which river it took its direction, with great rapidity, and disappeared a little above Blairgowrie. The effects were as extraordinary as the appearance. In its passage, it carried a large cart many yards over a field of grass; a man riding along the high road was carried from his horse, and so stunned with the fall, as to remain senseless a considerable time. It destroyed one half of a house, and left the other behind, undermined and destroyed an arch of the new bridge building at Blairgowrie, immediately after which it disappeared. As few appearances of this kind ever were attended with like consequences, various conjectures have been formed concerning it. Thanks to Ilias Chrissochoidis Ph.D. candidate Stanford University


DERA GHAZI KHAN -- On August 26, 2000, law enforcement agencies on Friday visited Khumbi Thalang in Tuman Gorchani tribal area of Rajanpur district where an unidentified flying object (UFO) crashed a few days ago. The Bahawalpur corps commander reportedly visited the site on Thursday. He along with other army officers inspected the 10-foot long piece of metal. The wreckage was taken away to unknown place in a covered container. The UFO was spotted flying over Balochistan on August 15. It was seen flying over Rajanpur, Loralai, Barkhan and Fort Munro area last week. It crashed some 20 kilometers away from Farid Air Base used by the Pakistan Air Force for exercises. According to local tribesmen, when it crashed at Khumbi Thalang, sky remained illuminated for about one minute. Editor's Note: The shape of the object would indicate it is some type of missile.


Michael O'Connor writes, The numerous stop-light green meteorites, fireballs or spheres seen in our skies are space ships. The drive inductor sucks in gravity in the front and pushes it out the back, propelling the craft. Elements in the air are caught in this flow and tend to build-up on the front of the craft. Gravity, now flowing through this build-up, induces a great friction creating a tremendous heat. The now molten build- up migrates under the craft and drips off, lending itself to the ancients description of a "Fiery Chariot". The molten and still glowing drippings were the "Burning Lamps" that fell from the sky. This "Coating" must be dispersed or else the functionality of the ship is impaired. It is blocking up the intake! The drippings cool as they fall through the air and when they hit the ground, they flatten a little, but still maintain their rounded edges. These drippings provide ample, but as yet unrecognized, evidence of extraterrestrial space craft.

People fall over them daily. Some are used as garden ornaments. Kids try to skip them over water, but they are commonly referred to as River Rocks. Scientists reveal that River Rocks are formed by tumbling or by the action of water, but have you ever seen a half formed River Rock? No. Why? Because they do not exist. These drippings were also responsible for the Chico mystery, where warm rounded rocks rained down on an old warehouse just outside of town. This phenomenon lasted for two years from 1921 through 1923. Are you interested in these things? Thanks to: Michael O'Connor (Michael O'Connor)


I asked LAN Fleming, "Do you have any thoughts about my comments that there seems to be a road, passageway, or canal between various sights at Cydonia?" The face, pyramid, and fort all seem connected. They also remind me of similar sites in Egypt and Mexico. One artifact can be explained away, but not the whole site.

Lan Fleming writes, "Yes, it's been noticed by other people that there are features that look like they could have been roads near some of the landforms, like the "Fort." Of course, they aren't definite enough to be totally sure they're not of geologic origin, but as you say, it's the totality of features in Cydonia that is compelling. Rather than monotonous repetitions of the same basic forms with minor random variations as is seen in most purely natural landscapes, there is a variety of puzzling features of sharply different form that seem to be related to each other in various ways, all in a very small region of the planet. We probably won't be certain what meaning, if any, is behind these apparent relationships until Cydonia is excavated in the way that Egyptian and Mayan ruins have been. I'm afraid that won't happen in our life time, though.


With sadness and regret, I am passing along the news that extraordinary South African UFO researcher Cynthia Hind has passed on after a lengthy illness. She was a totally marvelous person who was a great asset to the field of Ufology with her dignity and grace and solid intellect. We all will miss her.

If you enjoy Filer's Files every week and want to support my efforts, please make a donation via PayPal
I am offering fourteen years of Filer's Files on a DVD with thousands of photographs and sightings for a donation of $50 that includes this year's subscription. Please include your e-mail address and mailing address.


All real estate agents are not the same? Some real estate agents or sales representatives are part timers and inexperienced. Others are experts with an excellent experience and capabilities. When you are selling or buying your home, you need to make sure you have the best real estate agent working for you before you make any important financial decisions on one your biggest investments! Remember, the majority of people do not know the right questions to ask, and what pit falls can cause major problems. Picking the right real estate agent can be a wonderful experience, and picking the wrong one can be a big mistake that can waste your time and cost you thousands! Find out, " What you need to understand before hiring any real estate agent!" These are the questions that many agents do not want you to ask. Learn how you can obtain the best real estate agent for your needs. To get a free copy of this report, just call (609) 654-0020 or e-mail us at We can also help you with your own or corporate Worldwide Relocation to Australia, Benelux, Canada, Cayman Islands, England, France, Guam, Hong Kong, Israel, Japan, Mexico, New Zealand, Northern Ireland, Papua New Guinea, Philippines, Puerto Rico, and US.

PHOTOGRAPH BOOKLET of some of the best UFO shots available and data on their propulsion systems by US Navy Commander Graham Bethune.. $10.00. Send check or money order to G. Filer 222 Jackson Road, Medford, New Jersey 08055


For more detailed monthly investigative reports subscribe by contacting Mention I recommended you for membership.


Filer's Files is copyrighted 2000 by George A. Filer, all rights reserved. Readers may post items from the files on their Web Sites provided that they credit the newsletter and its editor by name and list the date of issue that the item appeared. Send your letters to Sending mail automatically grants permission for us to publish and use your name. Please state if you wish to keep your name, address, or story confidential.

George A. Filer and

Please subscribe or see the Filer's Files website for images in this weeks issue.